Listen to this article:
Key Takeaway
Ashtanga is structured and intense, while Vinyasa offers creative, fluid sequences for a dynamic practice.
The spiritual and physical practice of yoga has been around for thousands of years. In that time, it’s no surprise that several different styles of yoga have diverged from different teachers, philosophies, and areas of the world.
While all yogic practices offer universal advantages, certain styles are particularly suited to practitioner’s goals and preferences.
Two of the most popular styles are Ashtanga and Vinyasa Yoga. They have many overlapping traditions. Vinyasa originated as a branch of Ashtanga that has now taken on its form in the Western world.
If you’ve been wondering which style is best for your specific goals, here is everything you need to know about Ashtanga versus Vinyasa.
Contents
- 1 What is the Difference Between Ashtanga and Vinyasa Yoga?
- 2 What is Ashtanga Yoga?
- 3 What is Vinyasa Yoga?
- 4 Choosing the Right Yoga Style for Your Goals: Ashtanga versus Vinyasa
- 5 The Connection Between Music, Ashtanga, and Vinyasa Yoga
- 6 Key Takeaways: Vinyasa for Beginners & Ashtanga is More Intense
What is the Difference Between Ashtanga and Vinyasa Yoga?
Ashtanga is often called “power yoga”, while Vinyasa is sometimes called “flow yoga”. Ashtanga classes technically include Vinyasa flows during the Primary Sequence, which includes the classic Sun Salutation series.
To fully understand the difference between the two, let’s take a look at the sequence, intensity, class length, adjustments, and philosophical underpinnings of each style:
Sequence
The biggest difference between Ashtanga and Vinyasa is the rigidity of the sequence of postures.
In Ashtanga classes, you repeat the same sequence of poses in the same order every time. But in a Vinyasa class, there is more variation and interpretations of flow sequences.
Ashtanga traditionally encompasses six series:
- The Primary Series or Yoga Chikitsa: yoga therapy for your health
- The Intermediate Series or Nadishodhana: purify the nervous system
- The Advanced Series or Sthira Bhaga: center your strength. It includes Advanced A, B, C, and D series
However, modern Ashtanga classes are centered around the Primary Sequence, which is the most beginner-friendly. This sequence includes familiar Vinyasa flows such as Surya Namaskar A and B (sun salutations), in addition to a specific order of standing poses, seated poses, and chanting meditations. Repeating the same postures over and over again is designed to purify the body internally and externally through moving meditation that aids in aligning your chakras.
Vinyasa Yoga offers more variation and creativity. Every class can be a little different, though it includes many familiar asanas from the Ashtanga school of yoga. This style emphasizes the flowing movements and transitions between postures. It is almost like a fluid dance, and these classes are more likely to play music in the studio.
While both styles include flows, Vinyasa tends to be the most fluid and dynamic, while Ashtanga requires holding poses for longer periods of time.
Intensity
Ashtanga and Vinyasa Yoga differ drastically in their intensity. Ashtanga classes tend to be the most intense and rigorous, which makes them great for weight loss, muscle building, and physical fitness.
On the flip side, Vinyasa can also burn some major calories and build strength, but it is more accessible to beginners because it is less intense.
Generally speaking, people who practice Ashtanga yoga are often more “intense” yogis that diligently show up to practice in the early morning. Vinyasa tends to attract a more leisure crowd that wants to fit in a shorter practice at any time of day.
However, these are only generalizations and either style can be practiced as recreationally or seriously as you’d like. The moral of the story is that Ashtanga is significantly more intense.
Class Length
In regards to length, an Ashtanga yoga class takes at least 60 to 90 minutes to go through the Primary Sequence. Advanced power yoga classes can go as long as 2 hours.
Vinyasa classes tend to be much shorter (30 to 60 minutes), more varied, and better for beginners who are short on time.
Adjustments
Hands-on adjustments also differ in these two styles. An Ashtanga teacher is far more likely to offer adjustments and recommendations for alignment. This is because poses are held longer and can be more self-paced.
A Vinyasa teacher is is usually focused on leading the class and demonstrating postures rather than making adjustments to individual students. As the breath links continuous movement and certain poses are repeated, there is less time for modifications.
As in any studio, adjustments are completely optional and you should always let your instructor know if you don’t want to be touched.
Philosophy
You are probably already aware that practicing yoga encompasses far more than just physical postures.
Both Vinyasa and Ashtanga seek to sync breath with movement, improve mental focus, and help yogis achieve a deeper state of inner peace. But Ashtanga is significantly more spiritual and philosophical in its practice.
Traditional Ashtanga classes include meditation, chanting mantra, self reflection, and more intense breathing exercises. Ashtanga is centered around internal transformation and seeks to embody the full 8-fold path of yoga both on and off the mat.
However, when advertised as “power yoga”, Ashtanga styles may be solely focused on fitness and remove the spiritual aspects of the ancient style.
While a Vinyasa class will likely include some form of mental quieting and focus, it is less philosophical and doesn’t usually include chanting or designated meditative practice. Instead, the focus is on pranayama breath work, flow between different poses, and the external or physical experience.
What is Ashtanga Yoga?
Sometimes called “power yoga”, Ashtanga yoga originated as a philosophy proposed by an ancient sage named Patanjali. In the Yoga Sutra, he outlines the 8 fold path to enlightenment.
In the Western world, we most commonly think of yoga as asana, or physical practice. In reality, Ashtanga is a lifestyle of wholesome living that includes 8 core spiritual, moral, and lifestyle practices, including:
- Yamas: The first limb is all about morals and ethics. These ethical standards about life are the foundation of living the way of an ashtangi. Similar to the “Golden Rule”, yamas teach practitioners to essentially “treat others the way you want to be treated”. The 5 key yamas are ahimsa (nonviolence), satya (truth), asteya (non-stealing), brahmacharya (continence), and apirgraha (non-covetousness).
- Niyama: The second limb is based on self-discipline and spirituality. The 5 niyamas are saucha (cleanliness), samtosa (contentment), tapas (heat/fiery spiritual discipline), svadhyaya (studying oneself and the sacred scriptures), and isvara pranidhana (surrender to God or the Universe).
- Asanas: These physical body postures were originally meant to strengthen and prepare the body for long hours of meditation.
- Pranayama: Deep breathwork is a core pillar of both yoga and meditation. The literal translation of pranayama is “life force extension” because yogis have long believed that deep breath control improves and lengthens your life.
- Pratyahara: The fifth yoga limb relates to sense control or withdrawal from external stimuli. This means paying close attention to our bodies and the present moment.
- Dharana: Concentration is the limb that precedes meditation.
- Dhyana: Meditation and contemplation are the hallmarks of the seventh limb of yoga.
- Samadhi: The final stage or goal of yoga is complete absorption into the Universal bliss.
While these 8 pillars are central to Ashtanga Yoga philosophy, the way it is taught in the West tends to be centered around asanas. Nonetheless, devout ashtangis seek to apply these ethics both on and off the mat.
This style tends to attract a certain kind of person who enjoys the structure, discipline, and intensity of this fixed sequence yoga style.
Ashtanga Yoga is best for yogis who:
- Enjoy fitness and rigorous workouts
- Are athletes
- Want to lose weight or build muscle
- Are highly disciplined in self-practice
- Prefer a more spiritual experience
- Are looking to practice yoga for internal transformation as well as physical health
- Prefer the routine of a set sequence of poses
- Like to wake up early (many Ashtanga classes are around sunrise)
- Don’t mind getting super sweaty
- Enjoy a challenge
- Have plenty of time (90 minutes to 2 hours is standard)
What is Vinyasa Yoga?
Vinyasa Yoga is a somewhat “trendy” way of practicing yoga. It is technically a relative of Ashtanga that branched off to focus more on sun salutations and varied sequences. There is more creativity in Vinyasa flows and no two classes are the same.
Vinyasa Yoga is often called “flow” yoga because it is so focused on the transition between each asana and the next pose. A very common flow between challenging postures is often cued as “taking a Vinyasa Flow”. This means moving between Chaturanga Dandasana, Upward Facing Dog, and Downward Facing Dog.
While Vinyasa tends to be more beginner-friendly than Ashtanga, it can be particularly challenging for the wrists at first. Be sure to pay attention to proper alignment and posture during faster transitions.
Vinyasa Yoga is best for people who:
- Are beginners at yoga
- Enjoy fitness
- Want more flexibility and lean muscle tone
- Prefer a lower intensity, more leisurely practice (don’t get us wrong, the challenge depends on the yoga teacher and studio)
- Get bored with the same poses or prefer more variation (Vinyasa is creative and dance-like in its patterns)
- Enjoy practicing to music
- Like a modern take on yoga, rather than traditional yoga philosophy
- Only have time for shorter practices (30 to 60 minutes)
Choosing the Right Yoga Style for Your Goals: Ashtanga versus Vinyasa
When deciding between ashtanga and vinyasa, consider your yoga objectives. Each style provides advantages but caters to preferences and requirements. Let’s delve into the details to assist you in making a choice.
Ashtanga for Discipline and Structure
If you appreciate consistency, Ashtanga could be ideal for you. It follows a sequence every time, allowing you to track your progress effectively. Additionally, it offers a workout, making it suitable for those seeking a challenge. Individuals who value discipline and favor early morning routines tend to gravitate towards Ashtanga.
Vinyasa for Creativity and Flexibility
Vinyasa offers flexibility as each class varies from the next. This style is perfect if you seek variety and easily become bored with routine. It also tends to be more beginner-friendly. If you enjoy incorporating music into your practice and prefer diversity in movements, Vinyasa may be the right fit for you.
Ultimately, both styles offer benefits by enhancing flexibility, strength, and mental well-being. Trying out both can help determine which one resonates with you most effectively. Remember that the rewarding yoga practice brings enjoyment and consistency to your journey.
The Connection Between Music, Ashtanga, and Vinyasa Yoga
In Vinyasa sessions, music is commonly incorporated. It varies from soothing melodies to tunes. The music complements the flow of movements, enhancing their fluidity. Each beat seems to guide you from one pose to another, creating an ambiance that can enhance the overall practice experience.
Contrastingly, traditional Ashtanga practice typically excludes music in favor of focusing on the rhythm of the breath. This leads to a kind of experience where your breath serves as your internal soundtrack. It’s intriguing how this inward focus transforms the practice into a form of moving meditation.
I’ve personally noticed that whether there is music or silence, it can significantly influence my concentration and vitality during practice. In Vinyasa yoga, uplifting music boosts my spirits. Makes challenging poses seem manageable. On the other hand, in Ashtanga yoga, silence coupled with breathing deepens my sense of concentration and self-reflection.
Both approaches offer experiences without one being superior to the other; they simply provide perspectives on practicing yoga.
If you have a connection to music, Vinyasa might be the style for you. On the other hand, if you prefer an internal focus, you might find Ashtanga quiet practice more attractive.
Just remember, yoga is unique to each individual. Whether you prefer silence or music, choose what resonates best with your practice.
Key Takeaways: Vinyasa for Beginners & Ashtanga is More Intense
Ultimately, both of these styles of yoga have similar yoga poses and methodologies. The key difference between Ashtanga and Vinyasa is the structured versus dynamic patterns.
Vinyasa Yoga is better for beginners and includes a bit more room for creative interpretation. A great teacher will lead a flow class in a fluid, music-guided sequence that changes every time.
Ashtanga Yoga is more intense because it follows a set sequence of challenging poses and incorporates traditional spiritual practices. Those who teach Ashtanga may have different takes on this ancient practice, but the core series tends to remain the same.
Both Ashtanga Yoga and Vinyasa Yoga are excellent for:
- Improving flexibility and mobility
- Weight loss (Ashtanga tends to burn more calories)
- Improving mental health
- Strengthening and toning muscle
- Reducing stress
Many yoga studios offer classes in both styles, so we recommend experimenting to find what is best for you!
Namaste!
Pop quiz! 🧘🤔
Ashtanga Yoga classes always follow the same sequence of poses.
Vinyasa Yoga classes are longer than Ashtanga Yoga classes.
Both Ashtanga and Vinyasa Yoga incorporate breath work with movements.